Skip to content
Aerotex International logo

Resources / Explainers

Carbon vs Steel Business Jet Brakes: Weight, Wear, Cost and What It Means for Exchange

Carbon vs steel aircraft brakes for business jets: weight, heat tolerance, wear, taxi technique, overhaul cost drivers and which Learjets and Legacys use each.

· 8 min read · Aerotex International

If you fly a Learjet 45 and a Learjet 60, you’re already running both kinds of brake. The Learjet 40/45/75 and the Embraer Legacy 600/650 are listed with carbon brakes. The classic Learjets (25, 31, 35, 55, 60) are generally listed with metallic, steel-type brakes (confirm for your aircraft in the IPC and brake CMM). The two technologies wear differently, respond differently to how pilots taxi, and have different cost drivers when they go in for overhaul or exchange.

This guide explains the difference in practical terms for maintenance directors, chief pilots and parts buyers. It isn’t an engineering text. Where we give numbers, they come from the FAA and Boeing sources cited at the end. Your aircraft maintenance manual (AMM), component maintenance manual (CMM) and flight manual always take precedence.

Important: You can’t choose between carbon and steel brakes on a given aircraft. The brake type is set by the type design and the IPC. This article explains the differences so you can budget, read quotes and fly to get the most out of the brakes you have.

How a multiple-disc aircraft brake works

Business jet brakes are multiple-disc brakes. A stack of rotating discs (keyed to the wheel) and stationary discs (keyed to the brake’s torque tube) is squeezed together by hydraulic pistons. The friction turns the airplane’s kinetic energy into heat, and the stack has to absorb that heat and then get rid of it.

The difference between “carbon” and “steel” brakes is mainly what that stack is made of:

  • Steel (metallic) brakes use steel discs with friction material, often sintered metallic linings or wear pads riveted to the discs. The Rapco Fleet Support PMA kit for the Learjet 5003096-4/-6 brake, for example, lists rotating discs, 45 wear pads and rivets. One seller describes the Learjet 60’s 5003096-7 as a “tri-metallic” brake.
  • Carbon brakes use discs made of carbon fiber-reinforced carbon (carbon-carbon composite). The whole stack of rotating and stationary carbon discs is called the heat stack. The FAA describes carbon brakes as the latest version of the segmented multiple-disc brake.

Carbon vs steel at a glance

Factor Carbon brakes Steel brakes
Weight About 40% lighter than conventional brakes (FAA) Heavier
Heat tolerance Can withstand temperatures about 50% higher than steel component brakes (FAA) Lower; thin steel discs can warp
Heat dissipation Carbon rotors dissipate heat faster than steel rotors (FAA) Slower
Life Last 20–50% longer than steel (FAA); up to twice as many landings per overhaul (Boeing, airline data) Shorter
Main wear driver Number of brake applications (Boeing) Energy absorbed: weight and speed (Boeing)
Best taxi technique Fewer, longer, moderately firm applications Many light applications with cooling time
Main overhaul cost driver Heat stack Discs, linings/pads and hardware
Historical drawback Higher manufacturing cost (FAA) —

The Boeing figures come from airliner experience. Business jet brakes are much smaller, so use the direction of the comparison, not the exact numbers, when you think about your own fleet.

Weight and heat

The FAA’s Aviation Maintenance Technician Handbook says carbon brakes are about forty percent lighter than conventional brakes. It also says they withstand temperatures about fifty percent higher than steel component brakes, and that carbon rotors keep their strength and dimensions at high temperature. The handbook notes that the maximum design temperature is often limited by the components around the brake, not the carbon itself.

For a business jet, the weight saving is modest in absolute terms but still matters. The heat capacity matters more, because the brake has to absorb a rejected takeoff at maximum weight. That’s one reason newer, higher-performance designs such as the Learjet 45 family and Legacy 600/650 are listed with carbon brakes.

Wear: the difference that changes how you fly

This is the most useful practical point for operators, and it comes straight from Boeing engineers writing in AERO magazine:

  • Steel brake wear is directly proportional to the kinetic energy the brakes absorb. High weights and high-speed brake applications wear steel brakes fastest. Steel brakes last longest when pilots use many small, light applications during taxi and let the brakes cool between them.
  • Carbon brake wear depends mainly on the total number of brake applications. One firm application causes less wear than several light ones. Carbon brakes last longest when pilots let taxi speed build slightly above the target, then make a single firm application to bring it back below, instead of “riding” the brakes with many light touches. Carbon wear is much less sensitive to weight and speed.

Boeing stresses these are general taxi guidelines only, and that safety and passenger comfort come first. Your aircraft flight manual and operator procedures govern. For a mixed Learjet 45 and Learjet 60 fleet, it’s still worth briefing crews that the best habit for one brake type is the wrong one for the other.

Two other carbon wear factors are worth knowing:

  • Short legs mean more wear per flight hour. Because carbon wear tracks brake applications, a carbon-braked aircraft flying many short legs with long taxis can use up its heat stack much faster per hour than one flying long legs.
  • Oxidation and contamination. Research on carbon-carbon brakes has documented that some chemicals, including certain runway de-icing fluids, can speed up oxidation of the carbon. Follow the CMM and AMM for cleaning and inspection.

Inspecting wear on both types

Both carbon and steel brakes are usually checked with a wear indicator pin. As the friction material wears, the exposed pin gets shorter, and the manufacturer’s data gives the minimum length. The FAA warns that different brakes measure the pin in different ways, sometimes with the brakes applied, so always use the manufacturer’s procedure. Our Aircraft Brake Wear Pin Inspection Basics guide covers this in more detail.

Trend your readings. With carbon especially, plotting wear against landings and brake applications gives a much better replacement forecast than a generic “landings per brake” number.

What it means for overhaul and exchange cost

Carbon: it’s all about the heat stack

In a carbon brake overhaul, the heat stack dominates the cost. C&L Aero puts the heat stack at typically about 90% of a carbon brake overhaul cost. Overhaul shops may fit new carbon, refurbished carbon, or a mix. Boeing notes that improved overhaul procedures now let shops make better use of refurbished carbon material. So two quotes for the same carbon brake can differ a lot depending on:

  • New vs refurbished heat stack, and how much wear life the unit you receive has left
  • OEM vs FAA-PMA heat stack (PMA carbon stacks exist for some brakes, such as the Embraer 2-1699 family on certain ERJ models)
  • Whether the stack is included at all. ASI offers the Learjet 45’s 2-1579-2 with the stack “included” or “not included”

Steel: more parts, lower unit cost

Steel brake overhauls involve replacing worn discs, linings or pads, rivets and hardware. PMA kits are common on older types. Rapco Fleet Support’s kit for the Learjet 5003096-4/-6 is one example. The cost per overhaul is usually lower than a carbon heat stack, but steel brakes typically need overhaul more often.

Life-cycle cost

Boeing reports that for most airline operations, carbon and steel life-cycle costs are now similar. Carbon costs more per overhaul but lasts longer. For a business jet operator the brake type is fixed anyway, so the useful question is how to buy smartly. Duncan Aviation is another shop you may request quotes from:

Which business jets use which?

Based on published distributor and MRO listings (confirm with your IPC):

Aircraft Brake P/N (as listed) Type (as described)
Learjet 40 / 45 / 75 2-1579-2 (Goodrich/Collins) Carbon
Embraer Legacy 600 / 650 2-1699-2, 2-1699-3 (Goodrich/Collins) Carbon
Learjet 25 / 31 / 35 / 36 5003096-4, -6 (Goodyear/Meggitt) Metallic disc and pad (per PMA kit listing; confirm in CMM)
Learjet 55 / 60 5003096-7 (Meggitt); 55 also listed with -4/-6 “Tri-metallic” per one seller (confirm in CMM)

For Praetor and PC-12 brakes, see our Embraer Praetor 500/600 Wheels & Brakes Guide and Pilatus PC-12 Wheels, Brakes & Parts Exchange.

Frequently asked questions

Are carbon brakes better than steel brakes? Carbon brakes are lighter, handle more heat and usually last longer between overhauls. Steel brakes cost less per overhaul. On a certified aircraft the brake type is set by the type design, so it isn’t an operator choice.

Why do carbon brakes wear faster on short flights? Carbon wear depends mainly on the number of brake applications, not the energy absorbed. Many short legs and long taxis mean more applications.

Should pilots taxi differently with carbon brakes? Boeing recommends fewer, firmer applications for carbon and many light applications for steel, as general guidance. Follow your flight manual and company procedures.

What is a carbon brake heat stack? It’s the stack of rotating and stationary carbon discs inside the brake. It absorbs the braking energy and is usually the biggest cost in an overhaul.

Can I convert my Learjet 60 to carbon brakes? Not without an approved design change (such as an STC) for that aircraft. Check with your maintenance provider.

How do I know when a carbon brake needs replacing? Check the wear indicator pin against the AMM limit. Many operators trend readings to forecast removal.

Related reading

Get a brake quote or AOG support

Whether you need a carbon brake with a fresh heat stack or an overhauled steel brake for a classic Learjet, send us the part number, the condition you need and whether you want exchange or outright. We’ll quote it.

Taylor Mason, VP of Sales, Aerotex International
Phone: 469-293-3311 · Email: tmason@aerotex.net
For AOG orders, call 469-293-3311 directly.

For reference only. Always confirm part eligibility and procedures against the current IPC/CMM and your maintenance provider. This guide is general information, not regulatory advice. Always follow your approved maintenance data, your quality system and your regulator’s current guidance.

Need a part? Search by part number or send an RFQ.

AOGGrounded?