Exchange vs Outright vs Overhaul: A Cost Guide for Business Jet Operators
Exchange vs outright aircraft parts: compare upfront cost, core charges, downtime and risk against overhauling your own unit, with a worksheet for real quotes.

· 7 min read · Aerotex International
When a rotable part comes off a business jet, whether it’s a brake, wheel, starter-generator or avionics box, you have to decide how to replace it. The three main options are exchange, outright purchase and overhauling your own unit. On the quote, the cheapest-looking option isn’t always the cheapest once you count downtime, core risk and follow-up invoices.
This guide compares exchange vs outright for aircraft parts, adds the overhaul option, and gives you a worksheet for real quotes. We use the Learjet 45 brake as a running example because it’s a common, high-value rotable. The same reasoning works for any aircraft rotable exchange.
A note on prices: wheel and brake prices change with market supply, core availability and condition, so this guide doesn’t give dollar figures. Use the worksheet below with live quotes.
The three options in plain terms
Outright purchase
You pay the full market price (the “outright value”) and keep the part. You don’t return a core and you don’t get a later bill. C&L Aerospace notes that outright is also the only option for expendables and consumables, and is often required when you don’t have a core to trade.
Exchange
You pay an exchange fee, get a serviceable or overhauled unit right away, and return your removed unit (the core). The core charge shows up on the quote and becomes due if you don’t return an acceptable core. Exchange comes in three main forms:
- Flat-rate: repair of your core is included in the price, subject to conditions.
- Standard: the fee covers routine repair, and extra work is billed as over-and-above (O&A).
- Cost-plus: a lower fee upfront, then a second invoice for the actual cost of repairing your core.
For more detail on these, see Flat-Rate Exchange Explained.
Overhaul (repair your own unit)
You send your removed part to a repair station, pay for the work, and reinstall it when it comes back. You keep your own serial number and history, but the aircraft is down unless you have a spare.
How the costs add up
Outright
Total cost = outright price + freight
This is the simplest calculation. The part is yours and the cost is final. The trade-off is the highest upfront spend and the capital tied up in the part. On the plus side, you now own a spare, and later you can overhaul your old unit and keep it on the shelf.
Exchange
Total cost = exchange fee + (O&A or repair charges, depending on exchange type) + core charge if the core is unacceptable or BER + late-return fees, if any + freight both ways
How these add up depends on your core:
- Good core, flat-rate exchange: usually just the exchange fee plus freight.
- Good core, standard exchange: exchange fee plus any O&A beyond the standard allowance.
- Good core, cost-plus exchange: exchange fee plus the actual repair cost.
- BER core: the exchange fee plus the core charge. That can get close to (or beyond) the outright price.
C&L Aerospace defines “core value” as the difference between the exchange fee and the outright value. That’s why a BER core on exchange often ends up costing about what an outright purchase would have.
Overhaul
Total cost = overhaul price + parts beyond the quoted scope + freight both ways + cost of downtime (or of a loaner/spare)
Overhaul is often the lowest invoice. But you also have to count the time the aircraft isn’t flying, or the cost of a loaner or rental.
Comparison table
| Factor | Outright | Exchange | Overhaul your own |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Highest | Medium (fee) | Lowest invoice |
| Later invoices | None | Depends on type (O&A, cost-plus, BER core charge) | Possible extra findings |
| Time to return to service | As soon as the part ships | As soon as the part ships | Shop turnaround time |
| Core required | No | Yes | N/A (you send your unit) |
| Risk if your unit is badly damaged | None (you keep your old unit) | You pay the core charge | Large repair bill or condemnation |
| Keeps your serial number | No | No | Yes |
| Leaves you with a spare | Yes (after overhauling the old unit) | No | No |
| Best for | No core, building spares, BER-risk cores | AOG and scheduled ops without a spare | Planned work, operators with a spare |
The real deciding factor: downtime
For many business jet operators, downtime costs far more than the price difference between options. A charter aircraft that can’t fly loses revenue. A corporate aircraft that’s down can mean chartering a replacement. Only you know this number, so put it in the worksheet.
If an overhaul takes days or weeks and your aircraft has to fly, exchange or outright usually wins even if the invoice is higher.
Worked example: Learjet 45 brake replacement cost
Here’s how to work through the decision for a Learjet 45 brake assembly (Goodrich/Collins 2-1579-2, a carbon brake, per published distributor listings. See our Learjet 40/45/75 Wheels & Brakes Guide). Fill in the blanks with your own quotes.
| Line | Outright | Flat-rate exchange | Standard exchange | Overhaul |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part / fee | $____ | $____ | $____ | $____ |
| Heat stack included? | Y/N | Y/N | Y/N | Y/N |
| Expected O&A or extra findings | n/a | Usually $0 (check exclusions) | $____ | $____ |
| Core charge risk (if BER) | n/a | $____ × your probability | $____ × your probability | n/a |
| Freight (both ways) | $____ | $____ | $____ | $____ |
| Days aircraft unavailable | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ |
| × your daily downtime cost | $____ | $____ | $____ | $`{{{{ |
Things to watch on a carbon brake:
- Heat stack scope. ASI, for example, offers its 2-1579-2 with the stack “included” or “not included.” Make sure every quote you compare — including from Duncan Aviation or another shop — has the same scope.
- Wear at removal. A brake pulled at its wear limit is a normal core. A brake with heat damage, a seized piston or hydraulic leaks may come back with O&A charges or a BER finding.
- Condition code. An overhauled aircraft brake assembly (OH) and a serviceable one (SV) aren’t the same thing. Compare like with like.
Questions that change the answer
- Do you have a good core? If not, outright is usually cleaner.
- Is the aircraft AOG or is this planned? AOG favors exchange or outright. Planned work leaves room for overhaul.
- Do you keep spares? If you do, overhaul your own unit and rotate the spare in.
- How variable is the repair cost? High variance makes a flat-rate exchange worth more to you.
- What does the paperwork need to show? Make sure the part comes with the release documentation your operation requires (for example, an FAA Form 8130-3 and dual release if you fly internationally). The FAA notes that Form 8130-3 does not, by itself, approve installation on a particular aircraft. That’s still your call, based on the IPC and your maintenance data.
Hidden costs to ask about
- Core charge amount and when it’s billed
- BER threshold (it varies by supplier; one published example is repair cost above 55% of the core charge)
- Core return deadline (published examples range from 14 to 30 days) and late fees
- Restocking fees if you return an unused exchange unit
- Freight for both the unit and the core
- Warranty length and what it covers
Frequently asked questions
What’s the difference between exchange and outright for aircraft parts? Outright means you buy the part and keep it, with no core to return. Exchange means you pay a lower fee and send your removed unit back as a core.
What is a core charge in an aircraft exchange? It’s the amount you owe if you don’t return an acceptable core. It’s usually about the difference between the outright price and the exchange fee.
How much does a Learjet 45 brake replacement cost? It depends on whether you buy on exchange, outright or overhaul your own, on whether the heat stack is included, and on current market availability. Get live quotes and compare them using the worksheet above.
Is overhauling my own brake always cheapest? It’s often the lowest invoice. But once you count downtime or a loaner, exchange can end up cheaper overall.
When should I buy outright? When you don’t have a core, when your core is likely BER, or when you want a spare on the shelf.
Related reading
- Flat-Rate Exchange Explained
- Learjet 40/45/75 Wheels & Brakes Guide
- 3-1545-1 Learjet 45 Main Wheel
- Embraer Legacy 600/650 Wheel & Brake Part Number Guide
Compare real quotes
Tell us the part number and your situation (AOG or planned, core or no core) and we’ll quote exchange and outright side by side.
Taylor Mason, VP of Sales, Aerotex International
Phone: 469-293-3311 · Email: tmason@aerotex.net
For AOG orders, call 469-293-3311 directly.
For reference only. Always confirm part eligibility and procedures against the current IPC/CMM and your maintenance provider. This guide is general information, not regulatory advice. Always follow your approved maintenance data, your quality system and your regulator’s current guidance.
Need a part? Search by part number or send an RFQ.
