Skip to content
Aerotex International logo

Resources / Explainers

Core Charges, Core Returns and BER Explained

What a core charge on an aircraft exchange is, how core returns work step by step, how shops decide a core is beyond economical repair, and avoiding disputes.

· 7 min read · Aerotex International

Exchange is the fastest way to replace a business jet wheel, brake or rotable: you get a certified unit now, and you send your removed unit back. That removed unit is the core, and how it’s handled decides whether the exchange you were quoted is the price you actually pay.

Most exchange disputes aren’t about the replacement part. They’re about the core: it came back late, it was the wrong dash number, it arrived disassembled, or the shop declared it beyond economical repair (BER) and billed the core charge. This guide walks through the core return process step by step, explains how BER decisions are made, and shows how to avoid surprise invoices.

For how flat-rate, standard and cost-plus exchanges are priced, see Flat-Rate Exchange Explained. This article focuses on what happens to your core after the exchange unit ships.

Note: Core terms differ by supplier. The examples below come from published supplier terms cited at the end. Always read the terms on your own quote.

What is a core charge?

A core charge is the amount you agree to pay if you don’t return an acceptable core. It’s usually close to the difference between the exchange price and the outright value of the part. Suppliers often invoice it upfront and credit it when an acceptable core arrives, or invoice it only if the core isn’t returned or is rejected. Contact us for current core terms on Aerotex exchanges.

The core charge protects the supplier. They’ve sent you a certified unit from their pool, and they need your unit back, repairable, to restock the pool.

The core return process, step by step

1. Agree on core terms before the part ships

Before you issue the PO, get these in writing:

  • Return window. Published examples vary. Precision Aviation Group’s agreement asks for cores within 30 calendar days. VSE Aviation’s brake exchange program asks for the core within 14 days.
  • Core requirements. Same part number (and often the same modification status), complete, not disassembled, data plate intact, no incident damage.
  • BER threshold and what happens if your core is BER.
  • Over-and-above (O&A) terms, if it’s a standard exchange.
  • Who pays return freight.

In an AOG, it’s tempting to skip this step. Don’t. See AOG Aircraft Parts in Dallas–Fort Worth.

2. Remove and tag the core properly

  • Record the reason for removal and attach it to the core: wear limit, leak, damage, failed inspection, scheduled removal. Shops use it to evaluate the core, and some terms depend on it.
  • Don’t disassemble or “check” the unit. Cores that arrive opened or partly disassembled are commonly excluded from exchange terms.
  • Keep the data plate on and legible.
  • Leave the unit complete. Missing components may be billed.

3. Package it to arrive in the same condition

Shipping damage is still damage, and it can turn a repairable core into a BER one. Many operators reuse the shipping container the exchange unit came in, since it was designed for that part. For wheels with tires mounted, ask the supplier how they want the assembly shipped (deflated or not) and follow the applicable shipping rules.

4. Include the paperwork

Send the core with:

  • The supplier’s core return form or RMA, if they use one
  • Your PO or exchange order number
  • The reason for removal
  • Aircraft hours/cycles at removal, if requested
  • Any incident statement, if applicable

5. Ship within the window and keep the tracking

Late returns can trigger daily fees or the full core charge, depending on the terms. Ship promptly and send the tracking number to the supplier.

6. Receiving inspection

When your core arrives, the supplier or its repair station checks that it’s the right part number and serial number, that it’s complete, and that there’s no obvious shipping or incident damage.

7. Teardown and evaluation

The core is then disassembled, cleaned and inspected to the CMM. For wheels, that usually includes NDT such as eddy current inspection of the wheel halves. For brakes, it includes the housing, pistons and heat stack. This is where the shop finds out what it will cost to bring the core back to the condition of the unit you received.

8. Outcome

The evaluation usually ends in one of three ways:

  • Acceptable core. Repaired within the exchange terms. Done.
  • O&A charges (on standard exchanges). The shop found more work than the standard exchange covers, and you’re billed for the difference.
  • BER. The core costs too much to repair, or can’t be repaired, and the core charge applies.

How shops decide a core is BER

“Beyond economical repair” (BER) means the cost of repairing the core exceeds a threshold set in the supplier’s terms, or the core can’t be repaired at all, for example a wheel half cracked beyond CMM limits. A BER unit is only good as a parts unit — it isn’t serviceable, repairable or overhaulable.

Thresholds vary widely between suppliers. Published examples include:

  • Allaero: a core is BER when repair costs exceed 55% of the quoted core charge.
  • Precision Aviation Group: additional billing may apply when repair cost exceeds 75% of the flat-rate exchange charge.
  • Aerospace Support Associates (UK): BER is considered 60% of fair market value unless otherwise stated.

Because the reference point differs (core charge, exchange price, or market value), you can’t compare thresholds just by the percentage. Ask what the percentage is measured against.

Common reasons wheel and brake cores fail

The CMM governs the actual limits, but typical findings include:

  • Wheels: cracks found by NDT, corrosion beyond limits, damage to bearing bores or O-ring grooves, and heat damage, for example where thermal fuse plugs have melted. Shops list bearings, O-ring grooves and corrosion as common wear points on business jet main wheels.
  • Brakes: housing cracks or damage, piston or seal damage, and heat stack condition. On carbon brakes, the heat stack is often the largest repair cost, and its condition can decide whether a core is economical to repair. See Carbon vs Steel Aircraft Brakes.
  • Any part: incident damage (fire, flood, hard landing), missing data plates, or parts that were disassembled before return.

When your core is declared BER: your options

  1. Ask for the teardown report. Request the findings, photos and the CMM reference for the limit that was exceeded. A reasonable supplier will provide them.
  2. Check the terms. Confirm the BER threshold and what it’s measured against.
  3. Offer a replacement core. Some suppliers will accept another serviceable or repairable core of the same part number instead of charging the full core charge, for example a unit from your spares shelf.
  4. Ask about the BER core. Can it be returned to you, or will it be scrapped? If it’s scrapped, life-limited parts must be controlled under 14 CFR 43.10 so they can’t be reinstalled beyond their limits.
  5. Consider outright next time. If you regularly have cores that end up BER, buying outright (or knowing the BER risk upfront) may cost less. See Exchange vs Outright vs Overhaul: Cost Guide.

How to avoid core disputes

  • Get core terms in writing on the quote.
  • Match part numbers: return the same P/N and dash number you received. For Learjet brakes, for example, check dash numbers carefully on 5003096-series units.
  • Photograph the core and its data plate before it ships.
  • Ship promptly with tracking.
  • Don’t open the unit.
  • Disclose known damage upfront. A supplier may quote outright or adjust terms rather than surprise both of you later.

Frequently asked questions

What is a core charge on an aircraft part exchange? It’s the amount you pay if you don’t return an acceptable core (your removed unit). It’s usually close to the difference between the exchange price and the part’s outright value.

How long do I have to return a core? It depends on the supplier. Published examples include 14 days (VSE brake exchanges) and 30 calendar days (Precision Aviation Group). Check your quote.

What does BER mean? Beyond economical repair (parts unit only). The cost to repair the core exceeds the supplier’s threshold, or it can’t be repaired, so the core charge applies. A BER unit is only good as a parts unit — it isn’t serviceable, repairable or overhaulable.

Can I dispute a BER decision? You can ask for the teardown report, photos and the CMM limit exceeded, and check the threshold in your terms. Some suppliers will accept a replacement core.

What happens if my core arrives late? Late fees or the full core charge may apply, depending on the terms. Ship within the window and keep tracking.

Does a flat-rate exchange protect me from BER charges? Usually not entirely. Most flat-rate terms exclude BER, incident-damaged or disassembled cores.

Related reading

Questions about an exchange or core return?

Contact us for current core terms. Send us the part number, condition you need and your removed unit’s details.

Taylor Mason, VP of Sales, Aerotex International
Phone: 469-293-3311 · Email: tmason@aerotex.net
For AOG orders, call 469-293-3311 directly.

For reference only. Always confirm part eligibility and procedures against the current IPC/CMM and your maintenance provider. This guide is general information, not regulatory advice. Always follow your approved maintenance data, your quality system and your regulator’s current guidance.

Need a part? Search by part number or send an RFQ.

AOGGrounded?